Tuesday 10 May 2011

Strange Behaviors: part 1

I've been always interested in weird things (maybe I've watched too much "Tales From The Crypt" or Alfred Hitchcock's movies). I'm especially interested in weird/strange people. For me normal people and strange people are in something like yin-yang relationship. If there would be no “crazy” people there would be no normal people – we wouldn’t categorize anyone. And of course the boundary of normality is liquid and changes through times. Don't treat everything I've wrote too seriously because I tried to choose only more “entertaining” information (of course there are some serious exceptions).
  • Evidence in the history and how those strange behaviors were treated

    Strange people and their strange behaviors always existed. The methods of trying to help them were sometimes as weird as the patients (or even weirder).

    • Prehistoric times


      There is very little data on mental illnesses in the prehistoric times but scientists found many skulls after trepanation “treatment”. (Trepanation is cutting holes in the skull). Scientists speculate that this was the treatment for mentally ill individuals.
    • Ancient times

      • Egypt and Mesopotamia
        Archaeologists found some papyrus that mentions basic mental illnesses like hysteria, melancholy. People affected by this were treated with bodily fluids and magic spells. To improve effect they sometimes ate hallucinogenic foods.

      • Greece and Rome
        Socrates and Pythagoras had probably “command hallucinations”. (They heard voices and sometimes they obeyed voice's commands, thinking that they're possessed by a daemon). Celsus – the famous roman physician – described healing of mental illnesses by bloodletting, drugs, incubation in temple, exorcisms , incantation/enchantment (charm or spell created using words). Those were “civilized” methods of therapy. The not so civilized methods of therapy were: tortures and starvation till individual restores rationality, and if nothing else helps the unlucky fellow would be beat and/or stoned.

    • Middle ages

      • Persia, Arabia, Muslim Empire
        According to Islam's believes people with mental disorder are considered incapable (yet) to deserve human treatment and protection. Another thing is that first psychiatric hospital ward was founded in Baghdad in 705.

      • Christian Europe
        Most popular forms of treatment: purges (killing people with different opinions), bloodletting (as we see this was standard since ancient times), and whipping. Of course if there were suspicion of demonic/devil possession the individuals had to pray, receive exorcism and if it didn't work he was purged (killed). One of the most bizarre phenomena was dance mania. In wikipedia it is described as “a social phenomenon that occurred in mainland Europe. (…) It involved groups of people, sometimes thousands at a time, who danced uncontrollably and bizarrely(Is it only me or it sounds like some form of flashmob?).

    • Modern times

      • 16th - 18th centuries
        Victims of witch-hunts were admitted to local workhouses, poorhouses and jails (so does it mean that being mental was illegal?) . If you were homeless person you would also be qualified as mentally ill.
        In city of Bedalm people paid penny for watching the mental ill in madhouses (Could it be the foundation of entertainment of our times?).
        The naming of somebody mentally ill was straight-forward, you just call the individual crazy or insane (crazy means cracked in old English, insane means unhealthy).

      • 19th century
        First laws were introduced to compel authorities to deal with those who were judged insane by family and/or hospital specialists.
        In the USA it was proposed that black slaves who tried to escape were suffering from a mental illness and (theory) was called “drapetomania” (nowadays the theory is described as pseudoscience and racism).

      • 20th century
        In Nazi Germany, the institutionalized mentally ill were among the earliest targets of sterilization and attendees of euthanasia programs. It has been estimated that over 200 000 individuals with mental disorders were put to death. Later on they were joined by Jews and homosexuals in the Holocaust.
        Tools of 20th century science were:

        • lobotomies - when doctor cuts the connection between your two brain halves; often victims of this procedure can't control one side of their body.

        • Insulin shock therapies – patients were repeatedly injected with large doses of insulin in order to produce comas over several weeks. The procedure was introduced by Polish-Austrian-American psychiatrist. And as usual the therapy had very small percent of curing the patients.

        • Electroconvulsive therapy – treatment with high voltage.

        It's worth mentioning that in 20th century homosexuality was no longer treated as mental illness.

  • Causes of mental disorders

    The causes of mental disorders are complex and vary according to the particular disorder and individual. But there some patterns and similarities between them:

    • Genes
      Genetics often plays important part in tendency to have mental problems. But scientists till this day haven't found an evidence for it although they believe it is true and say that finding the genes responsible for it it is just a matter of time.

    • Pregnancy and birth
      Environmental events surrounding pregnancy and birth have been identified as one of the factors of developing mental illnesses in the offspring. This includes future mother's exposure to serious stress or trauma, famine, birth complications, infections, drinking alcohol or doing cocaine during pregnancy.

    • Diseases, injuries and infections
      Higher rates of mood, psychotic and substance (alcohol/other drugs) abusing are observed in people who had traumatic brain injury but the data is not enough consistent enough to draw a direct link between it.
      There are also some very bold theories that people infected by parasite “Toxoplasma gondii” tend to have schizophrenia. But as usual in psychology there is lack of solid evidence.

    • Individual features
      Hormones and bio-balance in the brain are very important factor because it can change in what way we see and receive information using our senses.
      Basically if you are unlucky you belong to the mentally ill side of the society. You can't even blame anyone because it is just pure (bad) luck.

    • Life events, stress and relationships
      Maltreatment in childhood and in adulthood has been linked to the development of mental disorders through complex interactions of other factors. Too much stress can even cause serious mental disorder.
      Parental divorce appears to increase risk of mental problems.

    Sources:

  • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_mental_disorders

  • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causes_of_mental_disorders

  • http://google.com

  • I've linked photos with sources of them

    Questions:

  • Would you pay to see patients of mental houses as a form of entertainment? Do you think that such practices are moral/immoral if this money would be used for food for the patients or overhaul those institutions buildings?

  • Did you ever seen any examples of mentally ill? Do you pity them or laugh at them? Maybe you feel other feelings? Tell us about it.

  • Are you afraid that some day you could be one of those mentally ill? (For me Alzheimer is one of the worst and scariest mental disorders).

  • Do you ever suspect yourself or your friends/family of having some sort of mental disorder(s)/problems? (Please don't answer too seriously ;)

11 comments:

  1. 1. I don't find watching mentally ill people entertaining, but who knows what could happen if we have lived ages ago? ;-) It's hard to decide if paying for watching such things is moral or not... I think it depends if it may be harmful to these watched people in anyway. Of course, if it may cause any kind of damage to them, it would be immoral.

    2. Mental illness are rather popular nowadays. I have friends with neurosis, depression, psychosis. Sometimes I think I attract people with problems. I try to be as good friend for them as possible.

    3. My grandfather and his sister suffered from Alzheimer disease so naturally I'm conscious it can happen to me.

    4. I have already answered for the last question :-) It's hard to not be serious when you have contact with people who suffer.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @asia
    I've also have many friends with mental illnesses and they prefer to laugh about it than cry about it. They hate special treatments, etc. It's pretty much similar to behavior of handicap people. Also you probably don't attract people with mental problems it's just plague of our times, everyone knows someone with mental problems. Not everyone withstands rat race. TV promotes that everyone should earn millions and be a movie star and that's not what life will turn out for most of us. ;)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I wouldn't pay money to go and visit such place and I wouldn't like to have such mental disease in future but who knows how it will be. After reading this point with paying to see, a picture came to my mind when there were floods in Poland last year - from one side there were people touched with this tragedy and from the other people that were going to those places and taking pictures there. What do you think those people who lost their homes felt like? I think that here (despite that they are mentally ill) they could feel similarly.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I wouldn't pay to see that patients. Why would I do this? :-) People can help them in other ways...
    I've seen mantally ill perfons few times but I tried not to laugh of them. They usually do funny things but It's not funny for them.
    I dont't affraid I could be mentally ill. I don't think of it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Heh, I used to watch it either.
    It seems to me that it isn't just a problem for ancient times only. Everything that's different and abnormal was and is strange and potentially dangerous for others. I would never pay for watching mentally ill people event if that money would go for the gold's jewelery for them. I saw few guys in my life - and that's enough. When I was a child I was being hospitalized for a week. There was a kid, who doesn't have everything alright with his mind. He was shouting all the time, destroying medical stuff and hurting other and himself - accidentally I guess. Then I was scarred like hell. If I ware able to decide I would never choose any of mental illness. That wouldn't be a problem for me (I wouldn't be aware that) but for my intimates it could. Alzheimer ?! Ahh, he is that German Guy who is hiding everything. For me "the funniest" mental illness is "Short-term memory disorder". People who continuously forgot what the did 2-3 minutes ago. After 2 minutes of normal talk patient is introducing himself once again. ...
    ...
    ...
    Hello I'm Tomasz and what's your article about?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well... laugh at them? It is not funny at all. I am really interested in every psychological topic. It is fascinating how powerful is our mind that in some cases we can’t overcome some mental illnesses. People are like in prison of their mind. Freaquently menetal illnesses are worse than diseases of body. Not without reason in many hopeless cases, specially conected with cancer, a strong hope and psychical state can make more than pharmacology. For me mental illnesses is just a horror... it is like a trap without an exit. Even a depression is not only a temporary weakness of psychical state but in many cases it’s a really dangerous disseas.


    I have a friend who had a depression and I know that many people neglects it and they don’t take it seriously but in fact it is very serious problem and it’s impossile to help them without a proffesional care of doctors. We should treat people who have some mental problems with a real respect because they are not crazy but seriously ill... and it is neither their fault nor their own free will.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think it sounds like something Cartman from "Southpark" could say. Generally he is an intolerant, extremely selfish and politically incorrect character. Cartman thinks that God made crippled people for his (ours?) amusement. I am so against this! I think only such a person would find watching mental ill people entertaining. Especially because in most cases - just as in case of people sick on their bodies not minds - the sight isn't that pleasant.

    This point of view always makes me sick and so sad... My younger sis has her half of brain damaged (cerebral palsy) , she needs so much attention and for me she is the most special person in the world. I will always portect her from people who laugh because of this :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I know a woman who is mentally ill.
    She behaves as if she was a teenager, and has 60 years of age.
    Her parents died and she lives alone. She has no husband or children, because she has always been a daughter of parents who did not let her grow up. Since the death of her parents she did not move their things, because she believes that they come back. It's really sad, she does not realize that needs help. She has cousins ​​who want her to give up treatment, but she interprets as an attack on her to take her money ...

    I hope that none of my family will not have to end up in such a place ...

    ReplyDelete
  9. I notice some people here tend to ask questions demanding morally complex and controversial answers. I wouldn't pay for watching mentally sick people, i don't want to be brought back to the middle ages. If you want to support the institution you can always donate some money.

    I deeply believe that 95% of people are mentally ill so yes, i have seen many. Each one has problems that can't be dealt with though it's mostly just in our heads. We are programmed since we are born, if something goes wrong according to the standards of programmation we suffer and have negative emotions. However we still consider ourselves healthy and those "really ill" are these who can't function in the society anymore. But as the society is ill, is being out of it even worse? Not necessarily. If someone goes crazy and bulids himself a little world of it's own and feels good in it - it's better than being unhappy in the so called "healthy" society.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think I would not pay to see patients of mental house as a form of entertainment since I see them almost everyday on the street. It is enough to go on the street and look around, there are thousands if not millions mentally ill people walking around you. When it comes to morality of such practices I do not think anybody including mentally ill people should be treated as exhibits in a museum. Paying in order to see people mentally ill is like going to the movies. Even if it was to be for a good cause such as food or renovation of buildings we cannot let them feel like animals in cages in zoos. Personally I have never seen any mentally ill people. But generally I never laugh at people who are mentally ill. It is like laughing at people who are ill. This can happen to you and imagine how you would feel if people laughed at you?! Usually when I think of mentally ill people I feel terrible that they have to suffer so much and that so little can be done to help them. I would not like to be mentally ill one day however I do take it into consideration. Nobody knows what life holds and what will happen in the future. I am afraid that I will not be independent till the end of my days and that people will have to take care of me which is unacceptable for me. Yes I do suspect that most of my best friends are mentally ill especially when I want to go out with them and almost anybody wants to go to different places. Even though I treat them as if they were mentally ill I still care about them and I do not know what I would have done if I didn’t have them around

    ReplyDelete
  11. 1. No, I would't want. For me it is mad idea. In my opinion it is also inmoral. Even if the money would be used for the sake of the inhabitors of the hospital. They are people, not monkeys in ZOO.
    2. I have seen mentally ill only on streets. For me it is simply sad.
    3. I hope not, but I am not afraid, because life is too short to be afraid of the future all the time.
    4. No.

    ReplyDelete